Opening archives won’t settle debate over Pius XII and the Holocaust

Whatever else Pope Francis’ decision on Monday, March 4 to open the archives from the pontificate of Pius XII in 2020 may mean, there’s one preliminary conclusion that seems take-it-to-the-bank, no-doubt-about-it, slam-dunk certain. Here it is: opening the archives will not – indeed, by definition, cannot – settle the historical controversy about Pius XII and…

Checking expectations for February child abuse summit
Letter from Rome   Under any circumstances, the announcement in September that Pope Francis plans to convene a summit on February 21-24 for all the presidents of bishops’ conferences around the world, along with the Vatican’s senior leadership, to discuss the clerical sexual abuse scandals in the Church would have been big news. After the…
To access this content, you must purchase The Irish Catholic Newspaper - Digital Edition, or log in if you are a member.

Is it now bishops versus everyone else?
Letter from Rome   Moments of great crisis generally affect institutions in multiple ways, some of which are immediately evident and others that take longer to discern. Amid the clerical abuse scandals currently rocking Catholicism, it’s worth asking if one such long-term result is playing out before our eyes. To wit, are we seeing a…
To access this content, you must purchase The Irish Catholic Newspaper - Digital Edition, or log in if you are a member.

Abuse bombshell effects Church’s ability to help children
Letter from Rome   A scandal’s impact can be measured multiple ways, with the most obvious being the toll it takes in terms of bad press, litigation and settlements, declining attendance or market share, as well as disillusionment and outrage among the rank and file. What’s often harder to assess is the opportunity cost – what…
To access this content, you must purchase The Irish Catholic Newspaper - Digital Edition, or log in if you are a member.

Pope Francis and Donald Trump’s problem with Putin
Letter from Rome   US President Donald Trump spent most of last week desperately trying to spin his controversial summit with Vladimir Putin [pictured below] as a breakthrough, despite widespread impressions of near-total capitulation on the question of Russian interference in the 2016 election. “The Summit with Russia was a great success, except with the…
To access this content, you must purchase The Irish Catholic Newspaper - Digital Edition, or log in if you are a member.

Climate in Islamic nation requires restraint, says Pakistan’s new cardinal
International Analysis Letter from Rome   For all those concerned with a rising tide of anti-Christian persecution around the world, certain things about the nation of Pakistan may seem blindingly obvious: that Shahbaz Bhatti, for instance, should be declared a martyr and saint, and that a death sentence for Asia Bibi should elicit outrage and…
To access this content, you must purchase The Irish Catholic Newspaper - Digital Edition, or log in if you are a member.

Seven thinking points on Pope’s creation 
of 14 cardinals
Letter from Rome   Arguably, no single thing any Pope ever does is more consequential than choosing the cardinals who will elect his successor. When a Pontiff reveals his picks for new members of the Church’s most exclusive club, therefore, it always delivers a powerful statement not only about where the Church is today, but…
To access this content, you must purchase The Irish Catholic Newspaper - Digital Edition, or log in if you are a member.