The population explosion: is there an ark to rescue us from the flood of childlessness?

The population explosion: is there an ark to rescue us from the flood of childlessness? Wikimedia Commons / Taymaz Valley.

The Pied Piper of Hamelin ends with the poignant scene of desolate parents in an empty square that no longer rings to the sound of their children’s laughter. That image came to my mind when Miriam O’Callaghan, in the RTÉ documentary, The Population Crash, surveyed an empty playground and mused, “a world without children, I hope I’m not around for that”.

The eerie fairytale tells a very different story of course. But there is a message for us nevertheless. Without a rising generation, there is no ‘ever after’, happy or otherwise. No children means no future. In Official Ireland, that message has not registered.

The big question posed by the programme was ‘Why?’ Experts and young adults, from Cahirciveen to Seoul, wrestled with the question, and offered various explanations.

The lack of affordable housing and high cost of living were factors widely cited. Undoubtedly, having a secure home is a necessary condition for family life. ‘Necessary ‘, however, is not the same as ‘sufficient’. Having a back garden is widely considered a necessary condition for having a dog but if everyone in Ireland was given a back garden not everyone will acquire a pet. It all depends on the social cachet attaching to dog ownership. If it’s seen as desirable then the provision of back yards for all would make a difference because our behaviours are largely the result of social mimesis.

Motherhood

Motherhood is not what our culture considers cool and aspirational. Rising panic in other countries at the implication of plunging births has produced a raft of financial incentives, including housing subsidies, but with no appreciable effect. In Ireland, not only has there been no effort in this respect but the Government and the National Womens’ Council of Ireland (NWCI), the Government’s policy stalking horse, have been actively downgrading the idea of motherhood.

They don’t appear to have any concerns at all about a popular TikTok platform called #nobabies which celebrates child-free life”

Despite being rebuffed by the electorate in their attempt to remove ‘mothers’ from the Constitution, they have doubled down in disparaging motherhood. They mounted a campaign to warn Irish women against an online platform promoting the idea of “the trad wife” because “such content can pressure women into limiting their career paths.

By contrast, they don’t appear to have any concerns at all about a popular TikTok platform called #nobabies which celebrates child-free life. The NWCI would probably support it as they see the “stigma of childlessness” still persisting in parts of Ireland.

Our Government is focussed on getting more women into the workplace and achieving gender balance in male-dominated sectors. Soon Irish companies with 50 or more employees will be obliged to submit a report to a Government platform with “their gender pay gap metrics”. The EU, unlike many of its member states, seems equally indifferent to tumbling birth rates. Their fixation with workplace arithmetic contrasts strangely with indifference to birth rates in freefall.

Pressure

The young adults who spoke to Miriam O’Callaghan, cited the pressure of career building as a key reason for delaying or even foregoing family life. However it’s not just parenting that’s on hold. There is the same stalling when it comes to forming committed relationships.

The cultural messaging is clear. Career building and personal empowerment are both societal and personal priorities. The message is pushed to a point where one might wonder if the feminine psyche is becoming permanently re-wired?

Since the sexual revolution, the equality narrative has run on two tracks. Women are entitled to the same opportunities as men, not just in the workplace but also in relationships. The presumption is that women as well as men welcome freedom from monogamous commitment that the new (anti-)reproductive technologies make possible.

This degradation of sexual relationships, exacerbated by the advent of the smartphone, was identified by two of the commentators in the RTÉ documentary – economists and journalists Dan O Brien and David McWilliams – as the prime reason for the population crash. The seemingly limitless variety of sexual experiences on offer online has captured men in particular with the result that many of them live life semi-vicariously in front of a screen rather than in the real world.

This helps explain the claims made by young adults from Ireland to South Korea, that it’s extraordinarily hard to find someone to marry. It sounds so counter-intuitive to people who grew up in the sixties and seventies, given the far greater mobility of today’s generation. Yet, that’s the reality for the attractive and articulate young adults who spoke to Miriam.

A viral article by British journalist and socialite, Petronella Wyatt, first published in 2024 is currently being re-circulated on social media. It’s a ‘cri de coeur’ for having fallen for ‘the feminist lie’. Wyatt wrote that she was “force-fed” a diet of radical feminism, was taught to put financial independence first and to think and act like men, and that many of those women like her, childless in their early and mid-fifties, now feel lonely and unloved.

For many viewers, the failure to mention the millions of babies lost to abortion was the elephant in the room of this documentary”

Petronella Wyatt has owned to having an abortion and it is indeed likely that this adds a deeper, darker layer to her regrets now. It is indeed interesting, but hardly surprising, that Miriam never mentioned the millions of babies lost to abortion and how that impacts the demographic and cultural changes the programme explored. For many viewers, the failure to mention the millions of babies lost to abortion was the elephant in the room of this documentary.

One disillusioned, young woman who spoke to Miriam in Seoul, is part of a female movement who believe life is better without sex, men, marriage or children. It’s pertinent to the point made by McWilliams and O Brien, that South Korea like Japan – with a birth rate of .7 and 1.1 per woman respectively – both produce and circulate hard porn on an industrial scale. So extreme is the content, the South Korean government took steps to make it illegal where specified acts including ‘realistic strangulation’ were depicted.

This girl is confronting trade-offs that even Petronella Wyatt’s generation never had to deal with. The scenario we are facing is bleak indeed. Concern that our demographic trajectory is heading towards a cliff is perhaps the beginning of a realisation that we are not functioning as human beings and human society is meant to function.

Correction

What will convince our elites our dysfunctional society needs a course correction? Are they likely to hear Pope Leo’s call to the very secularised Uruguayans last week, where he said “Young people, dare to take the step of marrying and starting a family yourselves. Do not be afraid of ‘forever’! Married couples, open your home to life, even when the world tells you that a child is a burden.”

People of faith already follow his counsel. This brings up the image of a figurative Noah’s Ark that offers humanity continuity and a future against the flood of human arrogance and hubris. This time it’s not just for a chosen few but for all who find Pope Leo’s words more inspiring than those of Gloria Steinem, Betty Friedan and the NWCI.